I am going to try to explain this as best I can. You MUST put yourselves in our position to answer this. If you're just going to come up with the first value judgment that pops into your head without trying to realize that the decision is being made in the context of our lives, which may have no similarity to yours, then you're just going to be harmful to another human being for no reason. We love our dog. He is a sweet boy and he's been a great member of our family. But he's 11.5 years old and has been going very slowly down hill for about the last 3 years. He has already popped the tendons in both of his back legs (We didn't treat it because we only knew he got hurt, we didn't know what it was. We gave him something for pain and he started walking better in a few days.). He has strange non-cancerous growths on various parts of his body, one of which is on the rim of his lower eyelid. It has to be insanely annoying. Now he appears to have a UTI of some sort that isn't clearing up on it's own (I gave him AZO and an appropriate dosage of aspirin at infrequent intervals and that seemed to give him some relief, but didn't cure it). He releases a lot of air when he urinates which makes us think he has a perforation in this bladder or intestine. Sometime in the next few days, probably Monday, I'm going to take him to the vet. If all he needs is antibiotics, I'll get them for him. If he needs any procedure/testing that can be done with up to $300, I'll probably do it. If it's any more than that, we're going to have a really hard time doing that. If he has cancer anywhere, I feel like I have to put him down rather than wait, which is hard for me because he still has a lot of mostly good days. All our money, such as it is, and all our energy, is tied up in just trying to get by day to day and taking care of our two little girls, one of whom has autism. We live in an unlivable apartment and have to move. The problem is, we're a working-class family and we have had some rough things happen, and we have a huge debt to landlord (that shouldn't be there but there's nothing we can do about it) from two years ago. We live in NY where apartments are crazy expensive unless you live in the 'hood (which we do now and no longer want to), and even the 'hood is getting pricey. We also have a circumstance happening here that necessitates moving very quickly (long story and this is long enough), so we have to ask a landlord not to charge us 3 months of rent up front, to ignore the dog, and to ignore the credit rating and bad rental history, and hope we actually get a good landlord and not one who takes advantage of people like us and runs the place like a slum (that's what we have now, and no thanks!) and I'm sure you can see how highly unlikely it is to find someone who will ignore all those things. I wish this wasn't so, but I have to consider the practical value of taking the one thing I can change, the dog factor, out of the equation if he's really just going to decline anyway, even if it's a couple of years earlier than it would otherwise have to be. I love this dog. But I feel like it might be a choice between him and housing my children. If credit reports were not allowed to contain things that affect a person's ability to obtain necessity of life things, like, oh, economy cars, non-luxury apartments and jobs, I would probably just keep treating whatever goes wrong with him until he just could no longer be repaired, but they do. I feel like I'm being backed into this. His quality of life is unlikely to improve. We just don't have time and money to improve it. I suppose I want to know if I'm thinking wrongly or rightly about this, but please, be a human being about this. Don't just say nasty things because you enjoy screwing with people. Nothing about this is easy or taken lightly. Thanks for reading all of this if you actually did. It had to be that long if people were going to understand the situation. RICHARD AND I CARE 4 U: Thank you both for your well-considered and kind responses. It means a lot to me. WENK, what's with slumlords is that they're greedy as hell, even compared to other landlords, and that takes a load of doing. They want to do nothing and collect unreasonable sums of your money and will do it until someone sends them to jail or they drop dead. Thank you for understanding and for your input. The thing is, we've had this boy for pretty near all his life. I found him when he was about six weeks old and he's going to be 12 in December. He's not healthy. I can't imagine his being adoptable however sweet and wonderful he is. I also think that on a certain level, to take him from his family and throw him in with someone else at this point in his life is almost more cruel than putting him down, especially given that his health really isn't great, and dogs you can always assume feel about 50% worse than they actually seem because they bear under it so well and don't complain until every single breath is painful.